Figs in Winter: New Stoicism and Beyond
Practical Wisdom
Plato on the need for expertise
17
0:00
-6:38

Plato on the need for expertise

Practical Wisdom podcast, episode 19
17

“[Lysimachus] ‘I am asking you, Socrates, because it seems as if our council needs someone to act as umpire.’

[Socrates] ‘What, Lysimachus? Do you intend to follow whatever course the majority of us recommends?’

[Lysimachus] ‘Yes, what alternative is there, Socrates?’

[Socrates] ‘Imagine there was some discussion about the kind of athletic training your son should practice: would you be influenced by the majority of us, or by the man who happened to have trained and exercised under a good coach. … I think that if a decision is to be made properly, then it must be made on the basis of knowledge and not numbers.’

‘So, what we should do now, first of all, is consider whether we have among us an expert in the subject we’re discussing or not. If we have, we should take his advice and ignore other people; and if we haven’t, we should look for somebody else.’” (Laches, 184c-185a)

17 Comments
Figs in Winter: New Stoicism and Beyond
Practical Wisdom
Practical Wisdom is a short weekly podcast produced by Prof. Massimo Pigliucci of the City College of New York. The idea is to sample the philosophical writings of a wide range of Greco-Roman authors in search of insights that may be useful for modern life. Currently, we are examining five works: Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics; Cicero’s Tusculan Disputations; Epictetus’s Discourses; Epicurus’s Being Happy (letters and aphorisms); and Plato’s early Socratic dialogues (Ion, Laches, Lysis, Charmides, Hippias Major, Hippias Minor, and Euthydemus). Available also on Apple, Google, and Spotify.